Theory, conceptual formula and methodology




The Democracy Ranking initiative applies the following conceptual formula for defining democracy and measuring the quality of democracy:

Quality of Democracy = (freedom & other characteristics of the political system) & (performance of the non-political dimensions).

This approach includes also the output of democracies. Democracy Ranking refers to countries (country-based democracies) with a population of one million or more and that are classified by Freedom House as "free" or at least as "partly free" (see also the Freedom House report). The Democracy Ranking makes explicit the "theoretical basis", which governs the theoretical self-understanding of the Democracy Ranking.

The Democracy Ranking understands and measures democracies in a multi-dimensional framework and approach. By this, the Democracy Ranking contributes to a further development of measurement of democracy. According to the ranking, democracy consists of six dimensions (one political, five non-political), with different weights for the overall quality of democracy. Their weights are distributed accordingly:

  1. politics (or the political system) 50%;
  2. gender (gender equality in socioeconomic and educational terms) 10%;
  3. economy (or the economic system) 10%;
  4. knowledge (knowledge society, research and education) 10%;
  5. health (or the health system and health status) 10%;
  6. and environment (environmental sustainability) 10%.

The theoretical basis of the Democracy Ranking encourages a broader approach for explaining and measuring democracy while covering and integrating non-political dimensions. This is enabled by an understanding that democracy represents not only a concept of the political system, but also a concept that extends to society and the context of society, and includes interfaces between politics, society, economy, and even the environment. Politics (policy) has or should have a responsibility for economic (socioeconomic) performance. Furthermore, there is also a need that democracy reflects the context of the (natural) environment.

Concepts of democracy turn out to be more demanding, the more they move from a mainly electoral democracy (emphasizing elections and political rights) to a liberal democracy (also encompassing civil liberties), and further extending to a liberal democracy of an advanced high quality. In that logic, the Democracy Ranking reflects and requires a "demanding type" of democracy.

Methodically, the Democracy Ranking does not create new indicators, but relies on already existing indicators that are being released regularly by renowned international and/or private non-profit organizations. The Democracy Ranking draws on available indicators according to a distinct conceptual formula and six-fold dimensional structure, thus providing a theoretically based conceptual design (a basic concept) of how to combine and aggregate these indicators. Depending on the source, the content of the indicators varies, extending from peer review assessment (for example, on freedom) to indicators that capture performance (e.g., socioeconomic behavior). The Democracy Ranking initiative acknowledges the work of organizations such as Freedom House, the World Bank, and also the United Nations Development Program (more specifically the Human Development Index).

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

50)India's Republic Day 2021: Just how this year's celebration vary

India Republic Day -- Highlights -For the first time since 1966, you will have no chief guest from the Republic Day Parade. -The parade will be shorter this year, instead of ending at the Reddish Fort, it will culminate with National Stadium. -The Mini stry of Information and Biotechnology will probably depict the 'Vocal regarding Local' initiative of the federal government. India is all set to celebrate its 72nd Republic Morning to honour the enactment of the Constitution of Of india which came into effect on January 26, 1950. Traditionally, the actual highlight of Republic Morning is the iconic parade that showcases India’s military prowess and cultural heritage. Although this year, the commemoration is going to be slightly different on account of the outbreak and events in the past year. Here is how Republic Day 2021 will be different: What cha nges have already been made for the parade caused by Covid? For the first time since 1966, there will be no chief visitor in...
Read more

Ranking 2016

Image
Source: Rank Country Score Political System Economy Environment Gender Equality Health Knowledge Gender Comprehensive 1   Norway 87.1 99.2 84.7 59.9 84.7 84.3 61.4 92.1 2    Switzerland 86.7 92.2 80.5 82.6 81.2 88.2 73.5 85.6 3   Sweden 86.2 97.4 67.4 71.4 85.3 84.8 66.2 91.0 4   Finland 86.0 99.7 63.7 60.6 84.7 82.1 70.2 92.4 5   Denmark 85.1 94.3 69.5 78.1 82.8 81.4 67.6 87.3 6   Netherlands 83.3 93.6 69.7 59.3 81.9 84.9 68.7 86.5 7   New Zealand 81.4 92.2 63.3 66.3 82.8 81.3 59.1 86.8 8   Germany 81.3 90.2 71.1 60.5 78.0 85.3 67.2 83.9 9   Ireland 80.9 91.5 63.2 71.9 75.8 79.4 61.5 84.2 10   Australia 80.5 87.6 69.8 59.9 83.6 83.6 70.0 84.8 11   Belgium 80.3 90.5 61.5 55.5 81.3 84.0 68.0 85.1 12   Canada 79.9 89.7 68.3 56.3 82.0 82.0 62.0 84.9 13   Austria 79.9 85.5 69.1 66.4 80.2 86.6 69.1 82.0 14   Unite...
Read more